Rejected after interview - long term impact
Hi,
I unfortunately screwed up a few interviews for buyside processes (1 FT and a few internships).
Post interview, some of the interviewer let me know that it was very close between me and a candidate, but the firm overall was happy to get to know me. Sometimes they offered a bit of advice ranging from working on a bit on motivation to better structuring my answers and similar smaller things. Some even offered to stay in contact or asked if I want to grab a coffee.
Anyways, I now super scared from a long-term career perspective. This may sound a unreasonable and stupid to more experienced professionals, but please hear me out. Having spoken to headhunters and people from HR, they talked about HR/Recruiters knowing each other and talking to about candidates. Moreover, I was also told, if you mess up an interview for a firm, they will often blacklist your name and circle the list to headhunters, to not send over that persons name.
Is all of this accurate? How much will those interviews screw me in the long-term? Can I still hope to recruit in a few years for a FT position? Also this is for Europe (in case this is relevant).
Thanks,
Moritz
Based on the most helpful WSO content, it's important to understand that while the finance industry can be tightly knit, the scenario you're describing is generally more of an exception than a rule. Here are some key points to consider:
Feedback is a Positive Sign: The fact that interviewers provided feedback and expressed interest in staying in contact is a positive indicator. It suggests that you made a good impression overall and they see potential in you. This is far from being blacklisted.
Industry Networking: While it's true that HR professionals and recruiters often know each other and may discuss candidates, this is typically more about sharing positive impressions rather than blacklisting. Blacklisting candidates is not a common practice unless there's a serious breach of ethics or professionalism.
Improvement and Reapplication: The advice given by interviewers is crucial. Work on the areas they highlighted, such as motivation and structuring your answers. Demonstrating improvement can make a significant positive impact when reapplying or applying to other firms.
Long-Term Perspective: A few unsuccessful interviews will not ruin your long-term career prospects. Many successful professionals have faced rejections. What matters is how you learn from these experiences and continue to develop your skills and network.
European Context: Recruitment practices can vary by region, but the fundamental principles of professionalism, feedback, and improvement are universal. Focus on building a strong skill set and maintaining good relationships within the industry.
In summary, use this experience as a learning opportunity. Continue to network, improve based on feedback, and apply again when ready. Your career is a long journey, and early setbacks can be turned into growth opportunities.
Sources: Odds I get rejected H1B as student from Europe, Life Goes On..., What to make of a rejection call?, Anyone ever went to a job interview where the recruiter had already made up their mind beforehand to reject you? And time wasted
Hic quos natus doloribus aut delectus. Eveniet aperiam incidunt dolore dolorum asperiores itaque. Voluptatem ut maxime dolor alias nemo sit.
Reiciendis omnis beatae laboriosam veniam ut repellendus. Nemo quaerat occaecati unde ea alias.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...