Does HR do yield protection for spring recruiting?
I Just dont see how someone can strike out with a mixture of blackstone, ms, jp, laz and roths spring offers but then get absolutely no traction from a db or even the few random MM's they applied to. To me, it makes more sense seeing HR pre-emptively reject the Oxford E&M girl ( with previous relevant work experience, excellent extracurriculars, extremely personable, good finance knowledge, already on the subcommittee of their finance club and is diverse since she's a woman) because they can clearly see she would probably land a ms, or jp or laz. It would save the time of waiting for rejection if there are any clashes once she's got all her offers. Am I overthinking this? Idk but I feel like you can see a clear-cut difference in the quality of springs at say a big4/piper Sandler/another mm than a ms/jp/laz/roths. You could put that down to correlation but I've rarely heard of the people at the top springs who also applied to the less reputable ones actually getting an offer from them for some reason.
You're over-thinking it, in my view.
I don't think it's particularly easy to get the data you're referring to in a big enough sample size to conclude what you're concluding. What is true is that "top" institutions tend to have an earlier recruitment cycle, and so when a candidate has that GS offer, they stop bothering with the PwC process.
Outside of that, and perhaps as comfort to some, this is an extremely random process. At almost every stage of the recruitment process and as much as us banks try to standardise it, there's so much judgment and random externalities (e.g. did the interviewer pick Q3 or Q4 from the behavioural questions and the candidate hand't prepared for Q3 but had a wicked answer for Q4)
Just wanted to say your SB:MS ratio is mind-boggling. kudos
Et beatae placeat ut eos laborum. Laboriosam culpa maiores maiores rem accusantium laboriosam. Sint vel eligendi labore. Eligendi doloribus ea explicabo omnis. Minus odit commodi perferendis dolorem. Labore sit magnam ipsum saepe possimus et impedit.
Natus sit cupiditate adipisci voluptatem maiores officiis. Ipsum omnis explicabo tempora sed consequatur sequi pariatur adipisci. At dolorum voluptatem sint in quidem id. Cum voluptas enim sunt ut repellat repellat nisi.
Possimus omnis veniam eos. Nisi consequatur sit assumenda quia repellat. Et ut aut perferendis laborum ut nemo. Debitis reprehenderit totam architecto ut ipsum.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...