Alternatives to Banking
(Monkey, 50
Points)
on 2/16/12 at 4:23pm
After reading all of these depressing health articles and finance consuming lives, I was wondering what kinds of jobs with in the IB industry offer similar risk/reward?
In reality, how much different is it working for a boutique/MM vs. a BB? I'm sure if you work hard and network, then opportunities in PE/HF's will present themselves.
Drop your knowledge and insight brothers.







boutique/MM hours are most
boutique/MM hours are most likely going to be worse than at a BB
finance is going to be a dead
finance is going to be a dead industry for the next 10 years. heed this or regret it. even for the people in it, the bonuses won't be growing. it was already a winner takes nearly-all kind of industry but now there will be fewer crumbs than ever for the middle level ass slaves.
if you have ambition learn programming languages and be a techie. For most bankers who are quanty, that's as close as you are going to get. Unfortunately most of you guys are too dumb to program (as am I).
melvvvar wrote: finance is
finance is going to be a dead industry for the next 10 years. heed this or regret it. even for the people in it, the bonuses won't be growing. it was already a winner takes nearly-all kind of industry but now there will be fewer crumbs than ever for the middle level ass slaves.
I'm curious why you see its decline. Outsourcing to China?
roommate is at a boutique, he
roommate is at a boutique, he leaves earlier than I do usually in the am say 7 and gets home around 10pm. Not sure if this answers or provides insight but he has pretty long hours obviously not the same as a MM or BB, I feel as if I never get out of here.....boutiques depending can be pretty sick to work at, he gets to travel a ton to Europe with the firms MD', goes to almost all the client road shows and attends the pitches for a first year analyst some of this is sick, given I never in a million years would get to do any of this. Exit ops I'm sure a boutique is not looked upon as favorably as a top MM or BB but then again who is to say you can't beat kids from these banks out, all about who you know most of the time not what you know and if you can make it rain at the boutique chances are you can do so elsewhere as well.
its one way or the other: hate me or admire.
1. new regulations up the
1. new regulations up the ass
2. balance-sheet crippled FIRE giants
3. sovereign, corporate and household deleveraging cycle
4. liquity trap (all financial returns have to come from operating returns eventually)
i know some wise ass college kid will come out and try to prove me wrong but i know what we are paying our junior people and i know the salary histories of the people around me. i also see the best people leaving the field for startups and non financial work. all signs negative.
I see a lot of people saying
I see a lot of people saying this but yet a lot of kids at the ivies still chase after banking.
Why?
If you expect a dog to bite you you'll be happy when al they do is pee on your shoes.
fruit loops wrote: I see a
I see a lot of people saying this but yet a lot of kids at the ivies still chase after banking.
Why?
normalcy bias.
fruit loops wrote: I see a
I see a lot of people saying this but yet a lot of kids at the ivies still chase after banking.
Why?
Banking is the best paying job one can possibly get for a guy with a non-technical degree and no experience / skills, straight out of school.
Most jobs outside banking/ consulting pay you 30-40k to start out. Need I say more to explain why those bunches of kids at Ivies are after banking gigs?
fruit loops wrote: I see a
I see a lot of people saying this but yet a lot of kids at the ivies still chase after banking.
Why?
A lot of these kids are still chasing banking, but it's markedly lower than before.
melvvvar wrote: fruit loops
I see a lot of people saying this but yet a lot of kids at the ivies still chase after banking.
Why?
normalcy bias.
Exactly.
Alternative to banking= S&T
Alternative to banking= S&T
JustADude wrote: boutique/MM
boutique/MM hours are most likely going to be worse than at a BB
can you shed more light on this? i believe it -- obviously the manpower issue is probably key, but are there any other factors to this?
I guess I'm just going to
I guess I'm just going to have to contemplate from now until next fall recruiting on whether I believe the 1-2 years of nothing but WORK are worth it? I want it bad, but am i willing to give up my health since it's already deteriorating in college? That's the concern.
Quote: Alternative to
Alternative to banking= S&T
Arguably a worse alternative if we're incorporating the economy and future focus on technology into our reasoning.
moneymogul
Alternative to banking= S&T
Arguably a worse alternative if we're incorporating the economy and future focus on technology into our reasoning.
Arguably a better alternative if we're incorporating hours and relative pay. Techology has already done its toll on s&t, arguably.
can i go straight to PE or do
can i go straight to PE or do i have to go to IB?
"Americans are in a cycle of fear which leads to people not wanting to spend and not wanting to make investments, and that leads to more fear. We'll break out of it. It takes time"-Warren Buffet
Does anyone think that the
Does anyone think that the hours will get better as the financial sector declines? It seems like they're going to have a more difficult time attracting people to work the same hours pre-crash but for a smaller bonus and probably small bonuses in the future.
I don't think very many
I don't think very many people go straight to P/E. I have potential one shot at an analyst position in a VC/PE firm and that's it so far
melvvvar wrote: finance is
finance is going to be a dead industry for the next 10 years
this time it's different/what's so special about 2022 anyway?
Moving tonnes of product. Making fat stacks.
Hayek wrote: Does anyone
Does anyone think that the hours will get better as the financial sector declines? It seems like they're going to have a more difficult time attracting people to work the same hours pre-crash but for a smaller bonus and probably small bonuses in the future.
Here's what I think: more work for the fewer bankers in the short-run, but in the long-run we'll see more banks specialized in their own niches. So, more of the banks like LAZ/EVR/GHL, more of Qatalyst/Centerview/Financo, etc.
i work pubfin and the hours
i work pubfin and the hours are 8-530 or 6, with occasional nights/weekends. the pay is markedly lower, though.
I'd still choose Goldman
I'd still choose Goldman Sachs or JP Morgan over Facebook in 10 years
Sexy_Like_Enrique
I see a lot of people saying this but yet a lot of kids at the ivies still chase after banking.
Why?
Banking is the best paying job one can possibly get for a guy with a non-technical degree and no experience / skills, straight out of school.
Most jobs outside banking/ consulting pay you 30-40k to start out. Need I say more to explain why those bunches of kids at Ivies are after banking gigs?
Commercial Real Estate my good man... Commercial Real Estate....
Need to Land a Job? Click Here.
rynofrowan wrote: melvvvar
finance is going to be a dead industry for the next 10 years
this time it's different/what's so special about 2022 anyway?
spitball estimate. when finance craps out it tends to stay that way for 10-20 years. i say we are about 5 years into the suckage.
Nobama88
I see a lot of people saying this but yet a lot of kids at the ivies still chase after banking.
Why?
Banking is the best paying job one can possibly get for a guy with a non-technical degree and no experience / skills, straight out of school.
Most jobs outside banking/ consulting pay you 30-40k to start out. Need I say more to explain why those bunches of kids at Ivies are after banking gigs?
Commercial Real Estate my good man... Commercial Real Estate....
Curious what they pay, if you don't mind me asking.
I had an interview for a spring internship in CRS. Turns out I got beaten out by a guy who took a class taught by a partner in the firm (so I had no chance). Will be working with a real estate guy for a week over Spring break though, and looking to get into it on the analyst level after graduation because my curriculum and the news have caused me to lose faith in the equity markets.
Plenty of options outside of
Plenty of options outside of banking if you can handle the loss of "prestige."
1. Corporate/commercial banking - companies will always need debt: revolving credit, short term loans, etc for working capital needs. Also loan syndication for LBO. 50-60 hours a week for 65-70k all in. Corporate bankers probably make same base with 10-20k bonus
2. F500 finance. This obviously isn't going anywhere. Companies are l going to need people to work FP&A, treasury, etc.
3. PWM managing rich guys money. Dumb rich people will always need this to be done for them. A couple of the BBs actually offer a typical analyst experience as opposed to being cold calling & running around to get AUM at the junior level sweatshop.
4. Big 4 accounting
Amphipathic wrote: melvvvar
finance is going to be a dead industry for the next 10 years. heed this or regret it. even for the people in it, the bonuses won't be growing. it was already a winner takes nearly-all kind of industry but now there will be fewer crumbs than ever for the middle level ass slaves.
I'm curious why you see its decline. Outsourcing to China?
Increased herfindahl indices and GINIs. Also a smaller pipeline of new companies and investment opportunities combined with investor skepticism, Finance's job is to:
1.) Merge small companies into big companies.
2.) Bring new companies to market.
3.) Help investors and investment opportunities meet.
4.) Transfer money from dumb money to smart money.
The 1980s-2008 really set us up well for 1, 2, 3, and 4. We started the '80s with low GINIs, highly regulated merger markets (low herfindahl indices), lots of investment opportunities, and lots of dumb money. With higher GINIs, the average dollar is held by someone who is richer- and arguably more savvy about money- than he was in the 1980s. So that's out. Higher herfindahl indices mean there are fewer companies to merge. Fewer investment opportunities means fewer companies to bring to market; fewer potential IPOs.
Those three things are the same problems that plagued the financial sector in the 1930s and 1940s. After the crash of 1929, the financial sector shrunk as a percentage of GDP for 25 long years.
History doesn't repeat itself, but it rhymes, and the 1980-2008 verse is setting itself up for a bad ending for the financial industry over the next thirty years.
Work hard, play hard.
There definitely is a certain
There definitely is a certain bias that IB/PE/HF is the end-all, be-all of a successful career; I for one used to think that as well. Logically, if you are surrounded by peers and superiors who are bankers, it will be hard to see any other successful career (other than the well known law/medicine fields). What I've realized is, is that there is a good amount of jobs outside of banking that offer plenty of reward in addition to a positive work/life balance.
For example at my aircraft financing firm, everyone here on the deal team gets paid bonuses of at least 50-100% of base, while the deal originators/structurers get bonuses in the multiples of base, much like the pay seen in banking. Plus the hours are very close to 9-5, with a good amount of international travel to meet with airline companies and their executive teams.
I would encourage others to look beyond the IB/Corp Dev/Big 4 net that this site has cast over most of your eyes; the world is a big place.
Open a debt collections
Open a debt collections agency. It doesnt have the glamour or prestige that many here are chasing, but it cost like $10k start the business. All you need is some phones and ex-cons to call people asking for money. Most agencys take in alteast 25% of the debt collected and being that we live in a nation that is in debt up to our eyes its a good venture.
bonks wrote: Nobama88
I see a lot of people saying this but yet a lot of kids at the ivies still chase after banking.
Why?
Banking is the best paying job one can possibly get for a guy with a non-technical degree and no experience / skills, straight out of school.
Most jobs outside banking/ consulting pay you 30-40k to start out. Need I say more to explain why those bunches of kids at Ivies are after banking gigs?
Commercial Real Estate my good man... Commercial Real Estate....
Curious what they pay, if you don't mind me asking.
I had an interview for a spring internship in CRS. Turns out I got beaten out by a guy who took a class taught by a partner in the firm (so I had no chance). Will be working with a real estate guy for a week over Spring break though, and looking to get into it on the analyst level after graduation because my curriculum and the news have caused me to lose faith in the equity markets.
I've always been interested in Commercial Real Estate... How big is the industry, and how hard is it to get a job in commercial real estate?
engieeriing has absolutely
engieeriing has absolutely awfl ramp up the world best programmer makes maybe 200k.
born2bebusiness wrote: bonks
I see a lot of people saying this but yet a lot of kids at the ivies still chase after banking.
Why?
Banking is the best paying job one can possibly get for a guy with a non-technical degree and no experience / skills, straight out of school.
Most jobs outside banking/ consulting pay you 30-40k to start out. Need I say more to explain why those bunches of kids at Ivies are after banking gigs?
Commercial Real Estate my good man... Commercial Real Estate....
Curious what they pay, if you don't mind me asking.
I had an interview for a spring internship in CRS. Turns out I got beaten out by a guy who took a class taught by a partner in the firm (so I had no chance). Will be working with a real estate guy for a week over Spring break though, and looking to get into it on the analyst level after graduation because my curriculum and the news have caused me to lose faith in the equity markets.
I've always been interested in Commercial Real Estate... How big is the industry, and how hard is it to get a job in commercial real estate?
Unless you go to a top school or are very good at DCF straight out of undergraduate, prepare for 2 - 3 years of mind-numbing work. There is a LARGE void in the CRE Finance arena, companies are always looking for finance people more than anything else. However most CRE firms (unless you are well connected) require 2 - 3 yrs of CRE experience - and working for a broker usually doesnt count. You have to pay your dues, but once you do, the money comes. Maybe not as much as IBD, but I have seen salaries up at about the 300k level for some jobs.
Also the beauty of real estate is anyone can do it. I mean I talk to people all the time who dont even have college degrees, but they own strip malls and other properties, pulling somewhat decent Cashflow from there properties (and this is in the middle of nowhere).
What about social finance, I
What about social finance, I heard this industry is up and coming. Any thoughts?
What are some good PE firms that focus specifically on sustainable investments?
waterloomonkey
engieeriing has absolutely awfl ramp up the world best programmer makes maybe 200k.
The world's best programmer (now that Steve Jobs has passed) also happens to be the world's richest person.
Work hard, play hard.
IlliniProgrammer
engieeriing has absolutely awfl ramp up the world best programmer makes maybe 200k.
The world's best programmer (now that Steve Jobs has passed) also happens to be the world's richest person.
I didn't know Carlos Slim was a programmer. Good to know.
theBEEGEES wrote: I didn't
I didn't know Carlos Slim was a programmer. Good to know.
One of the best out there at Ruby. I sat down with him at his computer and he showed me some sick stuff he designed.
Financial Modeling Training
Guide to Finance Interviews
Banking Resume
Tech is definitely the way to
Tech is definitely the way to go. I agree that those in the financial jobs will likely regret staying so long after a while. The banking industry keeps taking hits and with so many other ways to save money, it is only a matter of time.
Tech is definitely the way to
Tech is definitely the way to go. I agree that those in the financial jobs will likely regret staying so long after a while. The banking industry keeps taking hits and with so many other ways to save money, it is only a matter of time.
When people see how regulations and governments try to control too many things, like cardgames, then they will stand up and do the right things.
The truth is, there still
The truth is, there still aren't very many viable alternatives to IB for highly motivated students.
Law and Medicine have both declined to a far greater extent than finance. As depressing as the job market must be for graduating MBAs, the legal job market is worse. And who would go into medicine (4 years of grad school + a residency) with some sort of reform looming?
Consulting is attractive for the same reasons as banking; it keeps your options open, is prestigious, and pays well. The exits from consulting tend to attract a different type of person.
Tech, speaking from experience, will not take the place of finance. To get finance level compensation, you need to get in early enough to get some equity compensation. However, for every Facebook, there are 100 flops. Just going to work for an established tech firm won't make you rich fast, and climbing the ladder will take time like any other f500 job.
Entrepreneurship is awesome (and I think the country would be better off if more people tried it) but the highly motivated people who would be applying to IB/Consulting jobs are inherently risk averse.
So, finance is not what it was 2006-07, and probably won't be for years. But its still the "best" available option.
chuyoken wrote: i work pubfin
i work pubfin and the hours are 8-530 or 6, with occasional nights/weekends. the pay is markedly lower, though.
How low is the pay? Is it still 70K starting?
n1cktm wrote: Plenty of
Plenty of options outside of banking if you can handle the loss of "prestige."
1. Corporate/commercial banking - companies will always need debt: revolving credit, short term loans, etc for working capital needs. Also loan syndication for LBO. 50-60 hours a week for 65-70k all in. Corporate bankers probably make same base with 10-20k bonus
Isnt Commercial/Corporate banking starting salary 60-70K, then maybe 10-30k end of year bonus..
West Coast rainmaker
The truth is, there still aren't very many viable alternatives to IB for highly motivated students.
Law and Medicine have both declined to a far greater extent than finance. As depressing as the job market must be for graduating MBAs, the legal job market is worse. And who would go into medicine (4 years of grad school + a residency) with some sort of reform looming?
Consulting is attractive for the same reasons as banking; it keeps your options open, is prestigious, and pays well. The exits from consulting tend to attract a different type of person.
Tech, speaking from experience, will not take the place of finance. To get finance level compensation, you need to get in early enough to get some equity compensation. However, for every Facebook, there are 100 flops. Just going to work for an established tech firm won't make you rich fast, and climbing the ladder will take time like any other f500 job.
Entrepreneurship is awesome (and I think the country would be better off if more people tried it) but the highly motivated people who would be applying to IB/Consulting jobs are inherently risk averse.
So, finance is not what it was 2006-07, and probably won't be for years. But its still the "best" available option.
I don't know about Medicine, but prospects for Big Law is the same as it ever was. My ex-gf is a 2L at UPenn (Top 7), and according to her, V10 firms are within arms reach, provided you do some leg work.
Calling Ron Paul an isolationist is like calling your neighbor a hermit because he doesn't come over to your property and break your windows.
Can anyone talk about the
Can anyone talk about the base salary + bonus at a boutique//MM vs. a BB?
Leonidas wrote: I don't know
I don't know about Medicine, but prospects for Big Law is the same as it ever was. My ex-gf is a 2L at UPenn (Top 7), and according to her, V10 firms are within arms reach, provided you do some leg work.
I have some friends at comparable law schools, and while you certainly can get a V10 offer, it depends largely on GPA. Unfortunately, getting a decent GPA at a top lawschool is apparently something of a crapshoot.
There have also been layoffs in BigLaw, and it's a much bigger deal to lose your job as a legal associate than as a banker. Finally, the whole billable hour model is being called into question as legal services become commodities at the lower level. Cravath and Wachtell will always be fine. But there are way more students at t14 schools than there are slots at top firms.
To get back to the main topic, I also think banking will continue to exist, and be attractive, just because it is such an effective training ground. Hedge funds and PE firms will remain profitable barring any horrific government interference. If anything, alternative investments will become more vital to the economy if markets continue to stagnate.
Those firms demand the best trained monkeys, and IB supplies them. Until KKR starts regularly recruiting undergrads, people will go into IB with the hope of making it to the buyside. Which is really what they are already doing: almost all analysts leave after 2 years.
Nobama88
I see a lot of people saying this but yet a lot of kids at the ivies still chase after banking.
Why?
Banking is the best paying job one can possibly get for a guy with a non-technical degree and no experience / skills, straight out of school.
Most jobs outside banking/ consulting pay you 30-40k to start out. Need I say more to explain why those bunches of kids at Ivies are after banking gigs?
Commercial Real Estate my good man... Commercial Real Estate....
strong this
I banana back
IlliniProgrammer
finance is going to be a dead industry for the next 10 years. heed this or regret it. even for the people in it, the bonuses won't be growing. it was already a winner takes nearly-all kind of industry but now there will be fewer crumbs than ever for the middle level ass slaves.
I'm curious why you see its decline. Outsourcing to China?
Increased herfindahl indices and GINIs. Also a smaller pipeline of new companies and investment opportunities combined with investor skepticism, Finance's job is to:
1.) Merge small companies into big companies.
2.) Bring new companies to market.
3.) Help investors and investment opportunities meet.
4.) Transfer money from dumb money to smart money.
The 1980s-2008 really set us up well for 1, 2, 3, and 4. We started the '80s with low GINIs, highly regulated merger markets (low herfindahl indices), lots of investment opportunities, and lots of dumb money. With higher GINIs, the average dollar is held by someone who is richer- and arguably more savvy about money- than he was in the 1980s. So that's out. Higher herfindahl indices mean there are fewer companies to merge. Fewer investment opportunities means fewer companies to bring to market; fewer potential IPOs.
Those three things are the same problems that plagued the financial sector in the 1930s and 1940s. After the crash of 1929, the financial sector shrunk as a percentage of GDP for 25 long years.
History doesn't repeat itself, but it rhymes, and the 1980-2008 verse is setting itself up for a bad ending for the financial industry over the next thirty years.
All this talk of GINIs got me thinking...
Leonidas wrote: I don't know
I don't know about Medicine, but prospects for Big Law is the same as it ever was. My ex-gf is a 2L at UPenn (Top 7), and according to her, V10 firms are within arms reach, provided you do some leg work.
So, generally, I'm getting the sentiments that:
IBD/HF/PE/VC/PWM have fine outlooks.
Big law has a fine outlook.
Consulting, especially MBB, has a fine outlook.
Medicine, far as I can tell, has an iffy/poor outlook. Look, comp in medicine has been crap since the "usual and customary" fees stopped being paid. Not to mention the massive opportunity cost! If you're a smart fellow coming out of a target UG, and you've got the option of IB or MBB or going for med school, you'd make a huge mistake to go for medicine. Think about it: after 3 years in IB, you've made $300-500k less taxes, similar for MBB, but or 4 yrs in med school you're in debt at least $100k. For IB or MBB, you get an MBA, go back in as an associate in IB or in an HF/PE/VC, come back making $150k. During the same time, your average newly minted physician will be in a residency paying $40k for another 4 years. When he/she gets out, his/her starting salary is, tops, $250k. And that's in the tippy top specialties.
"When I was young I thought that money was the most important thing in life; now that I am old I know that it is."
- Oscar Wilde
"Seriously, psychology is for those with two x chromosomes."
- RagnarDanneskjold
Finance will come back
Finance will come back eventually. I'd rather stick it out during shitty times than miss the next boom.
I think two people going into
I think two people going into banking have a completely different goals than people going into medicine. People don't study medicine because they think they can earn big money. They go into medicine to help other people and stay in medicine.
The two groups have a totally different mentality.
Walkerr wrote: I think two
I think two people going into banking have a completely different goals than people going into medicine. People don't study medicine because they think they can earn big money. They go into medicine to help other people and stay in medicine.
The two groups have a totally different mentality.
Agreed...